2019 Store Hours
Baked Goods
Cookies
Sweet Breakfast Pastries
Bread
Pies and Sweets
Cakes
Decorated Cake Gallery
Dessert Cakes
Dessert Cupcakes
Everyday Cakes & Cupcakes
Wedding
Wedding Cake Gallery
Wedding FAQ's
Order Online
Baked Goods and Cakes
Cupcakes
Decorated Cakes
Tiered Party Cakes
Trailside Event Center
Menu
Established in 1861, Trefzger’s Bakery is proud to be Central Illinois’ oldest bakery!
2019 Store Hours
Baked Goods
Cookies
Sweet Breakfast Pastries
Bread
Pies and Sweets
Cakes
Decorated Cake Gallery
Dessert Cakes
Dessert Cupcakes
Everyday Cakes & Cupcakes
Wedding
Wedding Cake Gallery
Wedding FAQ's
Order Online
Baked Goods and Cakes
Cupcakes
Decorated Cakes
Tiered Party Cakes
Trailside Event Center
×
Filter: Cookies
All
Bread
Breakfast Pastries
Cakes
Cookies
Cupcakes
Pies and Sweets
Seasonal
Iced Butterfly Cookies
21.60
sold out
Thumbprint Shipping Box - Shipped
from
39.19
Special Border Sugar Cookies
9.19
Coconut Macaroons
from
10.00
Wheat-Free Thumbprint Cookies
14.19
Everyday Cookies
7.50
Iced Cookies
10.00
Our Famous Thumbprint Cookies
10.00
Peanut Butter Thumbprint Cookies
10.00
Fancy Flower Cookies
11.50
Religious Photoscan Cookies
from
30.00
Handcut Cookies with Buttercream Icing and Crystal Sugar
10.00
Scotch Cookies
7.50
Iced Pumpkin Cookies
11.00
Iced Ghost Cookies
11.00
Machine Cut Iced Cookies
10.00
Gingerbread Cookies
from
2.00
sold out
Turkey Shaped Cookies
11.00