It’s time to place your Thanksgiving orders!
Thanksgiving is Thursday, November 26th 2026
Tuesday 11/24: 6:30am-6:00pm
Wednesday 11/25: 6:30am-6:00pm
We will be CLOSED Thursday 11/26 - Monday 11/30
9” Wheat-Free Pumpkin Pie
Available September 5th - December only
REQUIRES A 3-DAY NOTICE!!
Not available in store; orders only
Sorry, no ingredient substitutions available.
*While this item is made from a Gluten-Free recipe, our kitchen is definitely not certified 'gluten free' as there is always flour drifting through the air, so if you are extremely sensitive this may not work for you.
Available in November only - Starting 11/03/26
Butter Cookie covered in Yellow Crystal Sugar and melted chocolate details.
Available in quantities of six or a dozen.
Pickup only!
Sold in quantities of one dozen in Seasonal Store colors. (I.e. red, green, and white in December)
Store colors vary with season. Pastel Colors and White are available year round at no additional charge.
Click here to order Custom Color Thumbprint Cookies!
Sold in Quantities of SIX
Decorators will choose the Deco unless you specify in the Extra Instructions at check out.
Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling
Available with or without sunflower seeds. Loaves with sunflower seeds cannot be sliced.
Available September - November!
Machine cut cookies, iced orange with green stem
September: Without Faces
October: With Piped Pumpkin Faces
November: Without faces
Sold in quantities of SIX or ONE DOZEN
Machine cut sugar cookies iced with our buttercream icing and decorated with seasonal colored glitter or sprinkles.
Sold in Quantities of SIX or ONE DOZEN
Sugar style cannot be chosen - will be a mix of what we have for that season (ex: fall leaves, pumpkins, Easter Bunny, Christmas, etc.)
Made with Soy and Rice Flours
Sold by the Dozen
Please allow Three Days notice for Wheat-Free Items
*While this item is made from a Gluten-Free recipe, our kitchen is definitely not certified 'gluten free' as there is always flour drifting through the air, so if you are extremely sensitive this may not work for you.
Shipping boxes will leave the store on Wednesday, November 12th 7 19th via USPS Priority two-day mail.
This box is built to fit 24 of our famous thumbprint cookies in two layers of one dozen each.
Orders must be placed by Friday at 4pm in order to be shipped by Wednesday of the next week.
The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.
Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.
Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.
Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your cookies for minimal breakage; however, thumbprints are a softer cookie and some crumbling may occur. Wheat-free thumbprints are more likely to crumble.
No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken cookies or late arrival.
This offer is only available online.
For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping
This box is built to fit one Chocolate, Butterscotch, or Oreo coffeecake.
Rough Coffeecake Dimensions: 10.5 inches x 8 inches
Orders must be placed by Friday at 3pm in order to beshipped on Wednesday of the following week.
The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.
Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.
Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.
Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your coffeecakes for minimal breakage; however, some crumbling may occur.
No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken products or late arrival.
This offer is only available online.
For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping
This small rate shipping box fits 16oz. of our Turtle Candy pieces. Pecan pieces covered in delicious caramel and melted dark chocolate.
Orders must be placed by Friday at 4pm in order to be shipped by Wednesday of the next week.
The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.
Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.
Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.
Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your cookies for minimal breakage; however, thumbprints are a softer cookie and some crumbling may occur. Wheat-free thumbprints are more likely to crumble.
No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken cookies or late arrival.
This offer is only available online.
For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping
This box is built to fit 12 of our cinnamon rolls in two layers of six each.
Orders must be placed by Friday at 4pm in order to be shipped by Wednesday of the following week.
The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.
Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.
Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.
Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your product for minimal breakage; however, some crumbling may occur.
No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken product or late arrival.
This offer is only available online.
For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping
This box is built to fit 24 of our coconut macaroon cookies in two layers of one dozen each.
Orders must be placed by Friday at noon in order to be shipped by Wednesday of the following week.
The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.
Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.
Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.
Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your cookies for minimal breakage; however, some crumbling may occur.
No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken cookies or late arrival.
This offer is only available online.
For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping