• 2026 Store Hours
    • About Us & FAQs
    • Contact
    • Donations
    • Order Online
    • Custom Cake Request
    • Wheat-Free & Vegan Products
  • Shipping Boxes
  • Gift Cards
    • Trailside Event Center
    • Wedding Cake Gallery
    • Weddings Through the Decades
    • Information
  • Allergens
Menu

Trefzger's Bakery

Established in 1861, Trefzger’s Bakery is proud to be Central Illinois’ oldest bakery!
  • 2026 Store Hours
  • About Us / Contact
    • About Us & FAQs
    • Contact
    • Donations
  • Order Online
    • Order Online
    • Custom Cake Request
    • Wheat-Free & Vegan Products
  • Shipping Boxes
  • Gift Cards
  • Weddings
    • Trailside Event Center
    • Wedding Cake Gallery
    • Weddings Through the Decades
    • Information
  • Allergens
×
  • Filter
  • All
  • Anniversary
  • Baby
  • Baseball
  • Birthday
  • Bridal
  • Cakes
  • Children
  • Chris
  • Christmas
  • First
  • Graduation
  • Holi
  • Holiday
  • Just For Fun
  • Milestone
  • Religious
  • Sports
  • Theme
  • Yule
← Back to Decorated Cakes-1

Round Cake with Piped Cubs Logo and Pinstripes

2017-02-17+12.19.22.jpg
2017-02-17+12.19.22.jpg

Round Cake with Piped Cubs Logo and Pinstripes

from $73.19

Please allow One Week notice for Special Decorated Cakes

Size:
Flavor:
Quantity:
Add To Cart
Round Cake Sizes/Servings
8 Inch 1 Layer 5 - 6 Servings
8 Inch 2 Layer 10 - 12 Servings
9 Inch 1 Layer 7 - 8 Servings
9 Inch 2 Layer 14 - 16 Servings
10 Inch 3 Layer 25 - 30 Servings

Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles
Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles
$37.00

Sold in Quantities of One Dozen

Choose Filled for White Fluff filling

Cupcakes
Plain Cupcakes
Plain Cupcakes
from $11.50

Cupcakes are sold in quantities of SIX or ONE DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Wheat Free Cupcakes
Wheat Free Cupcakes
from $18.50

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Available with Chocolate Fudge or White Buttercream Icing

Sorry, no ingredient substitutions available.

*While this item is made from a Gluten-Free recipe, our kitchen is definitely not certified 'gluten free' as there is always flour drifting through the air, so if you are extremely sensitive this may not work for you.

Read more →
Cookie Monster Cupcakes
Cookie Monster Cupcakes
from $19.50

Sold in Quantites of SIX or a DOZEN

With Chocolate Chip Cookies

Choose Filled for White Fluff filling

Read more →
2017-04-04 15.31.59.jpg
Fancy Spring Flower Cupcakes
from $19.50

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for white fluff filling

Read more →
Star Tip Iced Cupcakes in Your Choice of Colors
Star Tip Iced Cupcakes in Your Choice of Colors
from $12.30

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN.

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Minimum of 6 cupcakes per color and we do not have metallic gold or silver icing. Silver and Gold will be piped as gray and yellow gold.

Read more →
Smooth Iced Cupcakes in Your Choice of Colors
Smooth Iced Cupcakes in Your Choice of Colors
from $12.30

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Minimum of 6 cupcakes per color and we do not have metallic gold or silver icing. Silver and Gold will be piped as gray and yellow gold. List you color choices in the Extra Instructions box at checkout.

Read more →
Cupcakes with Flowers
Cupcakes with Flowers
from $13.50

Cupcakes are sold in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles
Photoscan Cupcakes with Sprinkles
$37.00

Sold in Quantities of One Dozen

Choose Filled for White Fluff filling

Read more →
2017-03-18 07.44.47.jpg
Dress Cupcake Cake
$66.50

27 White or Chocolate Cupcakes White Iced

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

*Colored icing is $0.10 extra per cupcake - In the Extra Instructions Box at checkout please specify you are looking for colored icing and and which colors. The additional charge can be paid for at pick-up.

Read more →
Cross Cupcake Cake
Cross Cupcake Cake
$63.10

24 White or Chocolate Cupcakes

Read more →
Cupcakes with Baby Booties and Rattles
Cupcakes with Baby Booties and Rattles
from $18.50

Cupcakes are sold in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Photo-Jul-28-2-59-05-PM.jpg
Emoji Cupcakes
from $19.50

Cupcakes are sold in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Basketball Cupcakes w/ Nets
Basketball Cupcakes w/ Nets
from $21.00

Basketball cupcakes are sold in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
aaa+(3).jpg
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Cupcakes
from $27.00

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
IMG_0213.jpg
Wedding Dress and Tux Cupcakes
from $72.00

Sold in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Owl Cupcakes
Owl Cupcakes
from $36.00

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling. 

Read more →
Barnyard or Safari Animal Cupcakes
Barnyard or Safari Animal Cupcakes
from $27.00

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling or Unfilled. 

Indicate type of Animals in Extra Instructions

Read more →
2017-03-03 13.34.00.jpg
Sport Ball Cupcakes
from $18.50

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Read more →
Beehive Decorated Cupcakes
Beehive Decorated Cupcakes
from $19.50

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Read more →
Panda Face Cupcake Cake
Panda Face Cupcake Cake
$60.00

14 Cupcakes

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Read more →
Horse Shaped Cupcakes
Horse Shaped Cupcakes
$69.00

26

If selected: cupcakes will be filled with our white fluff

Read more →
Cupcakes with Puffy Daisies
Cupcakes with Puffy Daisies
from $13.50

Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Read more →
Medical Deco Cupcakes
Medical Deco Cupcakes
from $27.00

Cupcakes with Medical Deco can be ordered in quantities of SIX or a DOZEN.

Deco includes a piped heartbeats and syringes.

Read more →
Baseball Cupcakes
Baseball Cupcakes
from $18.50

Piped Baseball Sold in Quantities of SIX or a DOZEN

Team Logo with Sprinkles Sold in Quantites of a DOZEN

Choose Filled for White Fluff filling

Read more →
Andes Mint Dessert Cupcakes
Andes Mint Dessert Cupcakes
from $18.50

Chocolate cake filled with white fluff, topped with mint whipped cream and Andes Mint pieces.

Cupcakes can be ordered in quantities of six or one dozen.

Read more →
St. Patrick's Day Cupcakes (Seasonal)
St. Patrick's Day Cupcakes (Seasonal)
$19.50

Available starting Tuesday, March 3rd 2026!

White or Chocolate Cupcakes with St. Patrick's Day Photoscan and Sprinkles

Sold in Quantities of 6 with 1 image per 6 or a dozen. Decorator will choose image unless you specify at check out.

Choose Filled for White Fluff Filling

Read more →
Italian Coconut Dessert Cupcakes
Italian Coconut Dessert Cupcakes
from $18.50

White cake with Italian buttercream filling, topped with Italian buttercream icing, toasted coconut, and a white chocolate piece.

Cupcakes can be ordered in quantities of six or one dozen.

Read more →
Chocolate Strawberry Dessert Cupcakes (Seasonal)
Chocolate Strawberry Dessert Cupcakes (Seasonal)
from $18.50

Strawberry Cake filled with Chocolate Ganache. Topped with Strawberry Buttercream and Chocolate Ganache Drizzle.

Cupcakes can be ordered in quantities of six or one dozen

Read more →
Angel Food Dessert Cupcakes
Angel Food Dessert Cupcakes
from $18.50

Angel Food Cake topped with Whipped Cream icing and your choice of Chocolate Ganache drizzle or Quins (pastel sprinkles).

Cupcakes can be ordered in quantities of six or one dozen

Read more →
Café Mocha Dessert Cupcakes
Café Mocha Dessert Cupcakes
from $18.50

Chocolate Cake with Mocha filling. Topped with Chocolate Whipped Cream and a Coffee Bean.

Cupcakes can be ordered in quantities of six or one dozen.

Read more →
Featured
Apple Cinnamon Chiffon (September)
Apple Cinnamon Chiffon (September)
from $12.19

September’s Chiffon Cake of the Month!

The Apple Cinnamon Chiffon Cake is a very light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Apple Cake iced in Apple Cinnamon Buttercream with Caramel Drizzle and Cinnamon Streusel

Read more →
Lemon Chiffon (January, May, August)
Sold out
Lemon Chiffon (January, May, August)
from $12.19

The Lemon Chiffon Cake is a very light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Lemon Cake iced in Lemon Buttercream.

Chiffon of the Month for January, May, and August

Read more →
Thumbprint Shipping Box
Thumbprint Shipping Box
from $47.19

This box is built to fit 24 of our famous thumbprint cookies in two layers of one dozen each. 

Orders must be placed by Friday at 4pm in order to be shipped by Wednesday of the next week.

The Pick-Up Date field is required to choose which Wednesday your shipment will leave the store.

Shipping boxes leave the bakery on Wednesdays via USPS Priority Three Day Shipping. Unfortunately, there is no guarantee of arrival date. We will provide a USPS tracking number via email the Tuesday before shipment.

Shipping and handling costs are included for shipping in the United States. International shipping is available for an additional postage fee.

Please keep in mind, we do our best to pack your cookies for minimal breakage; however, thumbprints are a softer cookie and some crumbling may occur. Wheat-free thumbprints are more likely to crumble.

No refunds will be issued by Trefzger’s Bakery for broken cookies or late arrival.

This offer is only available online. 

For additional shipping availability, please visit https://www.trefzgersbakery.com/shipping

Read more →
Strawberry Chiffon Cake (April,July)
Sold out
Strawberry Chiffon Cake (April,July)
from $12.19

April & July’s Chiffon of the Month

The Strawberry Chiffon Cake is a very light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Strawberry Cake iced in Strawberry Buttercream. 

Read more →
2017-03-22 09.03.57.jpg
Sold out
Easter Bunny Cookies (Seasonal)
$21.30

Oval Shaped Cookies Decorated As Easter Bunnies

Sold in quantities of 6

Read more →
Easter Bunny Petite Cake (Seasonal)
Sold out
Easter Bunny Petite Cake (Seasonal)
$22.49

2 - 3 Servings

Read more →
2017-03-22 09.08.07.jpg
Sold out
Easter Egg Cookies (Seasonal)
$14.00

Cookies Decorated iced Pink, Purple, Blue and Yellow Easter Eggs with Spring Glitter

Sold by the Dozen

Read more →
Irish Soda Bread (Seasonal)
Sold out
Irish Soda Bread (Seasonal)
$5.99

Available starting Tuesday, March 3rd 2026!

St. Patrick's Day Seasonal Special

Contains: Wheat Flour, Sugar, Buttermilk, Baking Powder, Baking Soda, Salt, and Butter.

Read more →
Guinness Bread (Seasonal)
Sold out
Guinness Bread (Seasonal)
$6.49

Available starting Tuesday, March 3rd 2026!

St. Patrick's Day Seasonal Special 

Contains: Flour, Brown Sugar, Guinness Stout, Butter, Baking Powder, and Yeast.

Read more →
Raspberry Chiffon (March, June, Nov.)
Sold out
Raspberry Chiffon (March, June, Nov.)
from $12.19

Chiffon of the Month for March, June and November.

The Raspberry Chiffon Cake is a light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Raspberry Cake iced in Raspberry Buttercream. 

Read more →
King Cake (Seasonal)
Sold out
King Cake (Seasonal)
$14.99

2026: Available Wednesday January 10th - Tuesday, February 17th

These are for pick-up only! If you would like to ship a King Cake please click HERE !

Available at the start of the Epiphany Holiday (1st week of January) - Fat Tuesday (Mid-February).

  • Danish Dough with Cinnamon Filling

  • Iced with Roll Icing and sprinkled with Purple, Green and Gold sugar

  • Small plastic baby figurine (Placed inside after baking)

Read more →
Heart Shaped Cake in Special Foil Pan (Seasonal)
Sold out
Heart Shaped Cake in Special Foil Pan (Seasonal)
$28.19

Available January 28th - February 28th 2025

Available in White or Chocolate Cake

Approx. 5-6 Servings

Read more →
BIG Chocolate Chip Cookies with Deco
BIG Chocolate Chip Cookies with Deco
$3.25

Available with Message Hearts, Puffy Daisies, or Seasonal Store Deco

If you are looking for specific deco please email order@trefzgers.com

Read more →
Special Border Sugar Cookies
Special Border Sugar Cookies
from $12.00

Sold in Quantities of SIX or ONE DOZEN

Sugar style cannot be chosen - will be a mix of what we have for that season (ex: fall leaves, pumpkins, Easter Bunny, Christmas, etc.)

Read more →
Chocolate Covered Strawberries (Seasonal)
Sold out
Chocolate Covered Strawberries (Seasonal)
from $15.00

AVAILABLE STARTING Friday, February 6th - Valentine’s Day

Sold by six or a dozen

Read more →
Chocolate Cherry Chiffon (February)
Sold out
Chocolate Cherry Chiffon (February)
from $14.19

February's Chiffon of the Month

The Cherry Chiffon Cake is a very light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Cherry Cake iced in Cherry Buttercream and Drizzled with Chocolate Ganache

Read more →
Everyday Cakes
Everyday Cakes
from $23.19

Everyday cakes do not come with decorations. If you would like decorations added, please CLICK HERE to order a decorated cake.

 

Read more →
Plain 8 Inch 2 Layer Cake with Flavored Buttercream Filling
Plain 8 Inch 2 Layer Cake with Flavored Buttercream Filling
from $28.19

10 - 12 Servings

Additional charge for writing or decoration

Read more →
Cream Puffs & Eclairs
Cream Puffs & Eclairs
$4.25

Made from Pâte à choux , a classic French dough that's used to make a wide range of pastries, from cream puffs to éclairs.

Cream Puffs are filled with pastry cream and topped with powdered sugar.

Eclairs are filled with pastry cream and topped with chocolate fudge icing.

Read more →
Coconut Macaroons
Coconut Macaroons
from $12.00

One Dozen

Read more →
Wheat-Free Thumbprint Cookies
Wheat-Free Thumbprint Cookies
$16.00

Made with Soy and Rice Flours

Sold by the Dozen

Please allow Three Days notice for Wheat-Free Items

*While this item is made from a Gluten-Free recipe, our kitchen is definitely not certified 'gluten free' as there is always flour drifting through the air, so if you are extremely sensitive this may not work for you.

Read more →
French Chocolate Torte
French Chocolate Torte
from $29.19

9 Inch 1 Layer - 12 Servings 

 

Read more →
Boston Cream Dessert Cake
Boston Cream Dessert Cake
from $38.19

Yellow cake with pastry filling and chocolate icing

Small - 8” 2 Thin Layers

Large - 8” 3 Thin Layers

Read more →
Orange Chiffon Cake
Orange Chiffon Cake
from $12.19

The Orange Chiffon Cake is a very light sponge cake with a very rich flavor.

Orange Cake iced in Orange Buttercream. 

Read more →
Angel Food Cake
Angel Food Cake
from $12.19

Available Plain or Iced in White Buttercream.

Read more →
8" Cream Pies
8" Cream Pies
from $12.99
Read more →
10" Fruit Pies
10" Fruit Pies
from $18.99
Read more →
Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal)
Pumpkin Pie (Seasonal)
from $12.99

Available September 5th - December!

Read more →
Pie Tarts
Pie Tarts
$3.25

Individual Cream Pie Tarts

Read more →
Cream Horns
Cream Horns
$3.25
Read more →

4416 N Prospect Rd

 Peoria Heights, IL 61616

(309) 685 - 9221

order@trefzgers.com / weddings@trefzgers.com